IMMAGINE AUSTRALIA BLOG

Australian immigration discussion and more...

IMMagine New Zealand Immigration Blog

Posts with tag: Australia

New Skilled Occupation List - Steady as She Goes

Posted by Myer on June 7, 2013, 3:55 p.m. in Eligibility

The Department of Immigration and Citizenship (DIAC) announced earlier this week the new Skilled Occupations List (SOL) that applies from 1 July.  The list was unusual only by virtue of the extent of the lack of change.  The following occupations are to be removed from the SOL

  • Hospital Pharmacist
  • Retail Pharmacist
  • Aircraft Maintenance Engineer (Avionics)
  • Aircraft Maintenance Engineer (Mechanical)
  • Aircraft Maintenance Engineer (Structures)

 

There were no additions.

We were expecting the occupation of Accountants to remain on the skilled occupations list but only those who are professional Accountants and Auditors.   

We  thought that some types of Accountants might be removed from the list because of the publicity surrounding the large number of Accountants that Australia grants residence visas to each year (40% of skilled migrants in the previous migration year were Accountants). However all Accountants remain on the Skills List. It would appear from their inclusion on the 1 July list that Australia still wants Accountants!

You can view the new SOL on the following link:

http://www.immagine-immigration.com/do-i-qualify/australia-immigration-policy/skilled-occupation-list/

Many of our regular readers would know that the Skilled Occupations List is significant in that only applicants nominating occupations on the SOL can submit independent subclass 189 visas. These visas are called independent because one does not need to be sponsored by a family member nor State government in order to be able to apply.

The vast majority of  skilled applicants do not have occupations on the SOL but have occupations on the Consolidated Skilled Occupations List (CSOL).   If your occupation appears on the CSOL you need to obtain sponsorship from a State government. There are eight States and Territories sponsoring various occupations which they select from the CSOL and SOL depending upon the needs of the economy of that particular State.

To view the current CSOL for July 2012 to 2013 (this includes the current combined SOL – Schedule 1 and CSOL – Schedule 2 occupations) please visit:

http://www.immagine-immigration.com/do-i-qualify/australia-immigration-policy/CSOL/

The above list will be updated once the new list is announced on 1 July.

Essentially State Governments do an audit of their economy in the months leading up to 1 July and then publish these lists. The lists show which occupations are in demand in that particular State for the new immigration year. They do not, however, indicate how many places are available for each particular occupation. 

Most States require you to have completed the English language test [IELTS] and obtain a positive skills assessment from one of the skills assessing authorities to confirm that you are, in fact, suitably qualified for the occupation that you nominate before you can apply for State sponsorship.

Most people make the mistake of waiting until such time as their occupation appears on a State Sponsorship List and they then arrange to do their skills assessment and sit the IELTS test. It usually takes three or four months to complete the skills assessment and IELTS test and by that time a particular State may have filled its quota of that particular occupation and that occupation is then listed is unavailable.

If this happens one has to wait until such time as it becomes available or consider applying to a different State if your occupation appears on another list and you are willing to settle in that State.

The new immigration year starts on 1 July and now is the ideal time to be completing IELTS tests and obtaining skills assessments so when the new lists are produced these formalities have been complied with and you are in the best position to take advantage of  the new State Sponsorship Lists.

The assessment as to which is the correct occupation to nominate is probably one of the most important and difficult aspects of a General Skilled Migration visa as each of the skills assessing body’s have different assessment criteria.

I should add that, for those occupations that have been removed from the SOL, don’t be too depressed, your occupations will still  be added to the CSOL and will be available through state sponsorship.

We will be presenting free seminars in Singapore and South Africa in June and for those interested in attending the seminar registration can be made through the following page of our website http://immagine-immigration.com/seminars/.

See below for schedule of forthcoming seminars. 

Forthcoming seminars :

 

South Africa

Johannesburg

Seminar will be held on Thursday 13 June at 7pm at the Michelangelo Hotel

Consultations will be held on 14, 15, 16, 24, 25 and 26 June in Auckland Park.

Durban:

Seminar will be held on Monday 17 June at 7pm at the Riverside Hotel

Consultations will be held on 18 and 19 June at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel.

Cape Town:

Seminar will be held on Thursday 20 June at 7pm at the Commodore Hotel

Consultations will be held on 21 and 22 June at the Commodore Hotel

 

Singapore

Seminar will be held on Saturday 22 June at 11am at the Holiday Inn, 11 Cavenagh Road

Consultations will be held on 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 and 28 June at the Holiday Inn. 

 

To book for the free seminar please go to www.immagine-mmigration.com/seminars.

Seminars are free to attend.  Should you wish to book a consultation there is a charge – to book consultations please contact Ruth on ruth@immagine-immigration.com


The Australian Dollar

Posted by Myer on May 30, 2013, 3:01 p.m. in Immigration

Notwithstanding having completed a BCom degree, majoring in Economics, I only “got” interest rates when I acquired my first mortgage. I can safely therefore say that I am no economist and feel on uncertain ground writing a blog on the value of the Australian dollar but I couldn’t help but  consider the implications of the softening Australian dollar on migrants.

The Australian dollar is currently trading at 0.96 against the US dollar having been as high as $1.05 earlier this year.

I remember when we emigrated from New Zealand to Australia in 2008. Like most migrants our house was our biggest asset and in retrospect we couldn’t have put our house on the market at a worse time (during the first months of the global financial crisis). We received an offer on the house which was less than we wanted and agonized over the decision until  I realized that the New Zealand dollar was very favourably priced against the Australian dollar at that time and  the gain in the favourable exchange rate would more than compensate for a lower sale price.

Many of my friends chose to retain property New Zealand and rent in Australia in the hope that the property market in New Zealand would recover and they chose to rent out their properties in New Zealand and in turn had to forgo the opportunity of purchasing property in Australia. All the while putting up with the hassle of obtaining tenants for their homes and managing the process remotely.

When we transferred the proceeds of the sale of our property the New Zealand dollar, was buying 0.87 Australian dollars.   The exchange rate subsequently fell to a low of 0.78, more than compensating for the softer sale price.

Why has the Australian dollar fallen in value?

1. Partly because of an 18 billion dollar budget deficit for the next financial year announced earlier this month.

2. The dollar's fall has been exacerbated by a rally in the US dollar against all major currencies amid expectations of a softening in its quantitative easing (money printing) program.

3. The carry trade which is where global investors who have the ability to  borrow cheap money in the US or Japan, Britain or Europe  and can do so at rates not too far from zero, using those funds to park cash in higher-yielding countries such as Australia and New Zealand.

4. The reduction in the Official Cash Rate (OCR) to 2.75 % - the lowest level in history

5. Lower worldwide commodity prices as the Chinese economy slows down

Whilst a lower Australian dollar does have some immediate benefits for migrants making  the immigration process cheaper and Australian housing [amongst other things] more affordable a heavy fall in the dollar, rather than a gradual decline, would be a clear signal of a fragile economy  and a deterrent for would be migrants.  So it’s a delicate balancing act, a softening in the currency is good because it makes Australian goods and services cheaper provided the economic fundamentals remain sound.

The Australian economy will only be in a perilous state if the commodity boom has run its course and if China is really in trouble, and the global economy more broadly is turning down.  This doomsday scenario is hardly likely to occur and Australia’s fundamentals appear strong.  Inflation remains at a healthy 2 – 3% and unemployment remains at 5 – 6%. 

Recent data shows the Chinese economy accelerating and jobs growth is surging in the US, hardly signs that the economic environment is deteriorating.

Ultimately the Australian dollar is going through a long overdue correction due to a combination of lower than expected economic growth, a fall in short-term interest rates and a fall in the terms of trade as global iron ore and coal prices adjust to rising supply and the reversal of capital flows.

Over the last few years I’ve really enjoyed the purchasing power of the Australian dollar. It’s made traveling abroad for Australians a lot more affordable but has made exporting product more expensive. As our product is Australia you can view the correction in the Australian dollar as a discount in consumer terms.

We were delighted to note that the Australian dollar fell not only against the American dollar but also against the relatively weak South African Rand and the Singapore dollar as well. The Rand strengthened from 9.71 in late March to a recent 9.22 and as far as the Singapore dollar is concerned it fell from 1.3 on 13 April to 1.21 yesterday.

If I knew how far the Australian dollar would ultimately fall I wouldn’t be sitting at my desk on Monday and you’d find me in a different career.  No one ever immigrates for profit and the experience is sure to set you back financially several years.  You have to accept that you are never going to get the best possible price for your house and never be able to obtain the  most favourable historic exchange rate  but if realizing your assets enable you to fulfil your dream of immigrating to Australia they should be viewed as having served their purpose.

For most migrants, attempting to understand the whims of the currency market is a bit like trying to understand how the immigration process works. You can read a lot, get a lot of opinion but frankly you are better off handing it over to someone who knows what they are doing. Just like you would plan out your move to Australia and when to take the couch, ship the pets and relocate your family, taking a strategic approach to your currency ‘relocation’ is always a smart idea. 

Most banks offer very simplified currency products that usually consist of a single one off deal based on your decision that the time is right. They generally wont offer much by way of advice (unless you have shares in a Fortune 500 company) and don’t reveal the tools that they have at their disposal to manage your currency transfers. For example one way to approach your currency needs is to set a ‘Market Order’ whereby you identify a reasonable price you want to achieve and then when the market hits that price your deal is done, whether you are asleep or out fishing. 

A good Foreign Exchange broker will analyse your needs, evaluate your objectives and provide relevant and useful advice to try and achieve those goals. They should be realistic about that advice and give you a practical solution to maximise your currency gains and hopefully minimise potential losses. 

Foreign Exchange brokers will also charge a lot less for their service than a bank, typically offering prices at 1.5 to 3% better than a retail banking institution, which on larger transfers can mean savings of tens of thousands of dollars. Rates vary between brokers, but often the advice you get is worth more than just the exchange rate. However like Immigration Advisers, Foreign Exchange Brokers are not all created equal. We know some very good ones who assist our clients with their financial migration, offering sound, practical and valuable advice.

 

Forthcoming seminars :

 

South Africa

Johannesburg

Seminar will be held on Thursday 13 June at 7pm at the Michelangelo Hotel

Consultations will be held on 14, 15, 16, 24, 25 and 26 June in Auckland Park.

Durban:

Seminar will be held on Monday 17 June at 7pm at the Riverside Hotel

Consultations will be held on 18 and 19 June at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel.

Cape Town:

Seminar will be held on Thursday 20 June at 7pm at the Commodore Hotel

Consultations will be held on 21 and 22 June at the Commodore Hotel

 

Singapore

Seminar will be held on Saturday 22 June at 11am at the Holiday Inn, 11 Cavenagh Road

Consultations will be held on 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 and 28 June at the Holiday Inn. 

 

To book for the free seminar please go to www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars

 

Seminars are free to attend.  Should you wish to book a consultation there is a charge – to book consultations please contact Ruth on ruth@immagine-immigration.com. 


What's in a Name

Posted by Myer on May 14, 2013, 9:52 a.m. in Lighthearted

Growing up I always thought of my surname as a bit of a curse and often wondered whether I came from a long line of Lipschitz' (or should it be Lipshi?) or whether some customs official with a nasty sense of humour changed my grandfathers surname from Jones to Lipschitz. 

Highly unlikely since my paternal grandparents hailed from Lithuania and prior to that, possibly Germany. Perhaps then my grandfather had the Lithuanian equivalent name to Jones prior to the whimsical humour of a customs official.

I have spent my life spelling my surname to people and to compound matters my first name, Myer, isn’t that common either. If people do know it they know it as a girls name and I often have correspondence addressed to me as Ms. 

So I do have some baggage with my name. I'm not going to tell you my middle name because you might think my parents were having an acid trip (it was the 60's) when I was born. 

Just in case you think I'm getting too comfortable on this metaphorical couch let me reassure you there is a point.

The point is that on a recent 24 hour stopover in Switzerland I was amazed how easily everyone understood and pronounced my surname. There were none of those awkward pauses when I have to finish the pronunciation of the name by adding " schitz" after they get as far as Lip.

From the receptionist at the hotel to the check in clerk at the airport prior to my departure everyone was Herr Lipschitzing me in Zurich. Even the counter staff at Starbucks got my first name correct when they named my cup. Yes I know ordering Starbucks in Switzerland looks bad but that's another story for another couch.

At the departure lounge I even heard that another Lipschitz was late for his flight to London over the intercom. I had to refrain from shouting "run Lipschitz you tardy bastard, you are letting the team down". I was starting to think that there are so many of us we are taking over the world. Today Zurich airport tomorrow...

The only other time I felt like this was when I emigrated from New Zealand to Melbourne 5 years ago. Like most migrants desperate for a sign that they are doing the right thing (particularly those of us dumb enough to do it at the height of the GFC) I noticed, on my first day in Melbourne, my first name Myer emblazoned in font 100,000,000 on the side of a large building. It's a sign, it’s a sign I thought to myself. God is showing me in a not too subtle way that the move to Melbourne was a good one. It was about as subtle as a burning bush in Collins Street but good on you Big Guy I thought to myself.

I subsequently found out it wasn't   through divine hand that my name ended up on the side of a building but rather it was the MYER department store. Apparently this other Myer was also a migrant but changed his name to Myer which leads me to believe that he must have had a really, really bad first name. Sadly - no relation.

So why am I ranting (as my wife unkindly says).  Although this might come across as some self indulgent piece of prose better delivered to a psychologist than an audience of would be migrants  it does have relevance to you so please don't rush me. Man this couch is comfortable, pass me another cushion Doc.

So when I  consulted with a very nice young Israeli on my recent trip and he tells me that he is thinking of changing his surname from Arabic to English (he is Jewish) and  do I think it's a good idea a wave of baggage descends faster than on a conveyor belt at Oliver Tambo International Airport (OK , much faster). 

His name did not contain any of the names Osama, Bin or Laden but it was unmistakably Arabic. Would this impact on his chances of getting employment in Australia he wanted to know.

I thought back to another Israeli client of mine who immigrated to NZ with my help many years ago. He was born in India and had the type of unpronounceable surname with so many guttural consonants that are so foreign to the NZ tongue. He told me that after a month in NZ and hardly any interviews he decided to change his name to something more English. Short of inspiration he looked to the bottle and found both inspiration as well as his new name - Johnny Walker! As Mr Walker the interviews started rolling in with a job offer soon thereafter.

I relayed the story to my young Israeli and after much laughter he confessed his love for whiskey as well. I bade the soon to be known Mr Daniels goodbye.

Was I facilitating a betrayal of his culture and heritage or making a difficult process easier. I prefer to think the latter. 

It's not racist for employers to want to employ people that they feel will fit into the work culture, relate better to their colleagues and customers and so people with more English sounding names do have an advantage. But that's not to say that people with more foreign sounding names can't overcome these initial obstacles, they can as soon as employers discover the person behind the strange name. 

After all, what’s in a name?

 

Forthcoming  free  seminars :

 

South Africa:

Johannesburg:  Seminar to be held on Thursday 13 June at the Michelangelo Hotel at 7pm

Consultations will be held on 14, 15, 16, 24, 25 and 26 June in Auckland Park.

 

Durban: Seminar to be held on Monday 17 June at the Riverside Hotel at 7pm 

Consultations will be held on 18 and 19 June at the Endless Horizons

 

Cape Town: Seminar to be held on  Thursday 20 June at the Commodore Hotel at 7pm

Consultations will be held on 21 and 22 June at the Commodore Hotel

 

Singapore:

Seminar to be held on Saturday 22 June at 11am at the Holiday Inn, 11 Cavenagh Rd

Consultations will be held on 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 and 28 June.

 

To book please go to our website – www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars


'I have 150 points, where do I start?'

Posted by Kane on April 5, 2013, 2:49 p.m. in Eligibility

Occasionally we hear from a potential client stating that they have scored 150 points on the skilled migration test, giving them sufficient amount of points to qualify and wish to start the process for migrating without the need for a consultation. Please forgive my scepticism when someone tells me that they have scored 150 points and meet the criteria when the highest score possible is 125 points. The vast majority of our clients struggle to reach 70 points.

At IMMagine we have a policy that we do not accept a client without first conducting an eligibility assessment so we can be sure that they do in fact meet the requirements (our visa success rate is better than 99%). So when you tell us that you don’t need an assessment, we would be foolish and unprofessional not to insist that we do our own check.

If you ever doubt the importance of an initial consultation prior to starting the migration process, you should think about the costs involved in migrating to Australia, and how difficult it actually is to qualify and be certain you meet the specific requirements.

You will note on our website that we do not have a self eligibility assessment available to our clients, unlike a number of other immigration agency firms. We find that these do not help anyone accurately assess the eligibility for migration to Australia as the assessment needs to be more in depth than just a  self-assessment points test and a few questions.  We find that  the self-assessment tests do more harm than good.

When going through the process of migrating one does not just deal with the department of immigration. There are several other decision making bodies concerned namely:

  • Skills Assessing authorities, with different requirements for each occupation
  • State Governments – In Australia, we have three levels of government and in many cases, you will need to deal with two of them. 
  • English Language testing

Whilst the self-assessment test gives an overview  for the  criteria under which points can be allocated , more often than not, those who are not familiar with the  legislation  upon which the points test is based,   will inevitably calculate the points incorrectly, usually overstating what can be claimed.  Over claiming points in an expression of interest leads to an automatic decline of the residence visa application. 

Self-assessment tests do not cover the requirements of the other important decision-making bodies listed above. You will also not understand the pitfalls and obstacles that can and will occur during the process, nor will you get a holistic assessment of your eligibility to qualify for a variety of visas to Australia. 

There are several reasons for inaccurate self assessments including:

  • Nominating the incorrect occupation
  • Overstating English language ability
  • Overstating work experience points, particularly where experience is not in the nominated occupation
  • Not understanding the differences between the two occupation lists, namely SOL and CSOL particularly in the context of state sponsorship/family sponsorship
  • Not understanding skills assessment and state sponsorship criteria

I can assure you that I have met many candidates who are working in an occupation on the skills list but would have absolutely no chance of meeting the skills assessment requirements. Unqualified Accountants is one that springs to mind. Unfortunately the skills assessment is a compulsory application in the migration process under points tested visas.

The migration process is so confusing with the Australian Migration Legislation being the second most difficult law in Australia behind the Tax Laws. We have met a number of people who have attempted the process themselves, spent money on filing fees, only to have had an application refused because they either didn’t meet requirements or miscalculated their eligibility assessment. 

Declined applications can have serious consequences  and can lead to applicants being prevented from filing further applications or character issues.

We have helped some of these applicants  who filed their own application, only to have it declined, obtain positive results  however  it makes life a lot more stressful (and expensive)  if the job isn’t done correct the first time round. 

I always say that the best money you can spend in the migration process is the initial consultation simply because you know from the start if you can actually meet the criteria or not. If you don’t then you’ll save yourself a lot of money in immigration costs.

If you do meet the criteria, then the investment in the process is well worthwhile as Australia is one of the best countries in the world to live.

 

Forthcoming seminars :  

South Africa – April  2013

Johannesburg: Thursday 18 April at the Michelangelo Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm

Consultations: 19, 20, 21, 28, 29 and 30 April. 

Durban: Monday 22 April at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm

Consultations: 23 and 24 April

Cape Town: Thursday 25 April at the Commodore Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm

Consultations: 26 and 27 April

 

Singapore – April 2013  

Singapore:

Saturday 27 April at the Holiday Inn – 11am to 12.30pm

Consultations: afternoon of 27 April, whole day 28, 29, 30 April, 1, 2 and 3 May.

 

Israel  – May 2013  

Tel Aviv

Sunday 5 May at the Park Plaza Orchid Tel Aviv Hotel at 7pm

Consultations: 6, 7 and 8 May.  

 

The seminars are free to attend but there is a charge for consultations.  You are not obliged to book a consultation.   

To book for the free seminar go to :  http://www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars/

To book for a consultation contact Ruth on ruth@immagine-immigration.com. 


Last Chance for Accountants?

Posted by Myer on March 15, 2013, 11:56 a.m. in Eligibility

 

Accountants, by all accounts, have had a good run as far as far as Australian immigration policy is concerned but is their Indian summer about to end on 1 July 2013?

There is speculation that the occupation of Accountant will disappear from the Skilled Occupations List (SOL) from 1 July of this year. In this regard we refer you to a newspaper article that appeared in The Australian Newspaper which appears at the end of this blog.

The effect of culling Accountants from the SOL would be that they would be relegated to the Consolidated Skilled Occupations List (CSOL).

The principal difference between the two lists is that if one’s occupation appears on the SOL one can, subject to scoring sufficient points, apply for the skilled independent 189 visa or the family sponsored 489 visa. For those with occupations on the CSOL one needs State Sponsorship.

There are eight States or Territories in Australia that publish lists of occupations they are prepared to sponsor for the forthcoming immigration year which runs from 1 July to 30 June.  In order to apply for State sponsorship one needs to sit an IELTS [English language] test and obtain a positive skills assessment for  a  specific occupation  before they could apply for State Sponsorship.

As part of a State Sponsorship application they would need to sign an agreement agreeing to live and work in that particular State for a period of two years.

At this point in time you would be excused for thinking …..   so what, Accountants could still qualify for General Skilled Migration visas even if their  occupation is  relegated to CSOL and you’d be right in that Accountants will, subject to obtaining State Sponsorship, qualify for general skilled migration visas however:

  1. Family members wouldn’t be able to  act as sponsors
  2. Accountants will not be able to migrate to any part of Australia but will be bound to settle in the State that sponsors  them  and this may necessitate  being removed from family members/friends already  located in Australia.
  3. Eligibility would be subject to a State sponsoring  your occupation  in addition to meeting  the additional criteria for State sponsorship. Most States would want to be satisfied that there are genuine reasons for you choosing that particular State and that you have researched your employment options in that particular State. State sponsorship involves more than obtaining a positive skills assessment for an occupation on a State sponsorship list
  4. State sponsorship lists change.  You never know how many “Accountants” each particular State is going to sponsor.
  5. It will become critical to choose the correct type of Accountant for the purposes of the skills assessment because State sponsorship lists  differentiate different types of Accountants . For example you might find that someone qualifies for a skills assessment for two occupations, namely External Auditor and  General Accountant.   There is no point in obtaining a positive skills assessment as an External Auditor if the State in which you are prepared to settle does not sponsor this occupation.
  6. With regard to 4 above, you may  find that by the time you obtain your skills assessment  the particular State that you had in mind might have closed its doors to  the occupation that you have had  assessed by the skills assessing authority,  necessitating  you to find a second State.  In this regard it’s going to be more difficult to substantiate that there are genuine reasons for you choosing the second choice State if you have already failed to obtain sponsorship from your initially preferred State.

In short I think Accountants will always qualify for a General Skilled Migration visa but instead of traveling first-class to Australia they will be traveling economy.  Accountants, welcome to the rest of us!

(see article below forthcoming seminars) 

 

Forthcoming seminars :  

South Africa – April  2013

Johannesburg: Thursday 18 April at the Michelangelo Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm

Consultations: 19, 20, 21, 28, 29 and 30 April. 

 

Durban: Monday 22 April at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm

Consultations: 23 and 24 April

 

Cape Town: Thursday 25 April at the Commodore Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm

Consultations: 26 and 27 April

 

Singapore – April 2013  

Singapore:

Saturday 27 April at the Holiday Inn – 11am to 12.30pm

Consultations: afternoon of 27 April, whole day 28, 29, 30 April, 1, 2 and 3 May.

 

Israel  – May 2013  

We are in the process of booking a seminar in Israel in early May 2013. Please email ruth@immagine-immigration.com if this is of interest to you. 

 

The seminars are free to attend but there is a charge for consultations.  You are not obliged to book a consultation.   

To book for the free seminar go to :  http://www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars/

 

Below is a story which appeared in “The Australian” on 23 January 2013. 

 

Change in migration list adds up to fear BY: JOHN ROSS From: The Australian January 23, 2013 12:00AM

UNIVERSITIES fear another crash in international enrolments as a debate rages about whether accountants should stay on a key migration priority list. The federal government and the Finance Sector Union say Australia is awash with overseas-born accountants. They say the profession should be removed from the 192-strong Skilled Occupation List, which governs eligibility for independent skilled migration. But accountancy bodies say demand for accountants is outstripping supply, while institutions fear the move could jeopardise up to $2.5 billion in revenue. They fear a re-run of 2009, when skilled migration reforms precipitated a downturn that has stripped $3bn a year from education exports.

Latest figures suggest about 28,000 foreigners study accountancy at degree level, representing 12 per cent of about 230,000 overseas higher education enrolments. But the International Education Association of Australia said far more were at risk. It said accountancy was effectively interchangeable with the broader field of management and commerce, which attracts one in two international higher education students. "Many segue into accounting once they find their feet and work out the finance and tax systems," said IEAA executive director Phil Honeywood. "Accounting is the professional end game of a business degree." With international higher education tuition fees totalling $5bn a year, accountancy alone could be bringing in between $600 million and $2.5bn in fees. 

The Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations said qualified accountants are in surplus and that all three categories - general, management and taxation accountants - should be removed from the Skilled Occupation List. "Employer sponsored migration is more appropriate to meet labour market needs," it said. 

Mr Honeywood said the move would create "enormous perception problems. It will indicate that Australia doesn't need any more accountants. "Students who had hoped to get employer sponsorship will no longer see us as a study destination." Monash University demographer Bob Birrell said Australia hosted about 60,000 25 to 34-year-old foreigners with management and commerce degrees. Just 30 per cent worked in management or professional positions, compared to 67 per cent of their domestic equivalents. "We do have a very substantial stock of these people in Australia," he said. 

Tomorrow bureaucrats, the FSU, business deans, private colleges, peak industry bodies and representatives of the big four accountancy firms will thrash the issue out at a Canberra focus group convened by the Australian Workforce and Productivity Agency. AWPA reviews the Skilled Occupation List annually and proposes changes to the federal government. It has flagged accounting as an occupation being considered for removal. It expects to forward its advice to the Immigration Minister in March or April, with the new list likely to apply from early July. AWPA chief executive Robin Shreeve said people shouldn't jump to conclusions about the new list. "We put a lot of research into this and we do a lot of data mining," he said. Mr Shreeve said tomorrow's meeting demonstrated that AWPA had an open mind and was "exploring every avenue". 

 

Source: The Australian 


“ So, what is Adelaide like?”

Posted by Myer on Jan. 23, 2013, 4:35 p.m. in Lifestyle

I get this a lot, prospective migrants inquiring as to a local context for a particular destination in Australia whether it be Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney or Kalgoorlie?


With this question in mind I spent a small portion of my holiday visiting Adelaide. Why Adelaide? My immediate response is “why not?” but this sounds a bit defensive. From an immigration perspective South Australia [of which Adelaide is the capital] is an attractive proposition.


Because the vast majority of our clients will require state sponsorship and South Australia sponsors one of the biggest arrays of occupations of any state it has immediate attraction. In fact, that list of occupations available for sponsorship just got longer. This past week South Australia added 33 occupations to its list of occupations available for sponsorship and the list appears below.


South Australia is also attractive because it includes Adelaide  in the definition of “regional”  for the purposes of the 489 visa. Therefore, unlike most states in Australia the capital city of South Australia is not excluded for a 489 visa meaning that the applicant can live and work in Adelaide on a 489 visa. This is quite different from a 489 visa sponsored by the states which exclude Perth, Sydney and Melbourne from areas in which applicants can live and work for a period of two years.


I had no preconceptions in mind as to what Adelaide was like and must confess to being very pleasantly surprised by Adelaide. I found the architecture to be a mixture of modern and colonial in a friendly juxtaposition of contrasting styles. I found the city to be neatly organized in a logical grid system, plenty of parks and enough of a commercial hub to feel part of the international community [Adelaide has 1.1 million people] but still not living in a rat race.


I was surprised by Adelaide’s charm.


If pressed to find an equivalent city I have to say Cape Town comes closest. Apart from the obvious comparisons given the viticulture industries in both South Australia and the Cape some of the streets have a similar feel.


The architecture is obviously different, Cape Town having a distinct Cape Dutch feel with an influence of British colonial architecture. Adelaide doesn’t have the Cape Dutch influence but does have the colonial architecture and the city has a similar size and feel.

Don’t make the mistake of going to Adelaide looking for Cape Town. It’s not Cape Town and has a quaint charm all of its own.


If you want to find out more about what South Australia has to offer I suggest you look at the South Australian Government website which gives a very good overview as to the economy, weather, cost of housing etc.


On my trip I managed to meet with a representative of Immigration South Australia [a State Government organization] and was told that one of the selling points of Adelaide is quality of life for families, providing a good work life balance with quality education, affordable housing and internationally recognized qualifications. The vast majority of our clients are looking for this lifestyle and if this appeals to you give some thought to migration to South Australia.

Forthcoming seminars

South Africa

Johannesburg : Thursday 7 February at the Michelangelo Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm
Consultations: 8, 9, 10, 18, 19, 20 February

Durban: Monday 11 February at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm
Consultations: 12, 13 February

Cape Town: Thursday 14 February at the Commodore Hotel – 7pm to 8.30pm
Consultations: 15 and 16 February

Singapore and Malaysia

Singapore:
Saturday 23 February at the Holiday Inn – 11am to 12.30pm
Consultations: afternoon of 23 February, whole day 24, 25, 26, 27, 28 February and 1 March

Kuala Lumpur:
Saturday 2 March at the DoubleTree by Hilton, , The Intermark – 11am to 12.30pm
Consultations: afternoon of 2 March, whole day 3, 4, 5 and 6 March

The seminars are free to attend but there is a charge for consultations.  You are not obliged to book a consultation.  

To book for the free seminar go to :  http://www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars/)

The following occupations have been added to the State Nomionation Occupations List 

ANZSCO OCCUPATION
133511 Production Manager (Forestry)
134111 Child Care centre manager
135112  ICT Project Manager
135199  ICT Managers, nec
139999  Specialist Managers nec
142114 Hair or Beauty Salon Manager
149411  Fleet Manager
149913  Facilities Manager
224711  Management Consultant
224712  Organisation and Methods Analyst
225212 ICT Business Development Manager
234112  Agricultural scientist
234311  Conservation Officer
234312 Environmental Consultant
234313  Environmental Research Scientist
241111  Early childhood (pre-primary school) teacher
251111  Dietitian
252112  Osteopath
252211  Acupuncturist
252214  Traditional Chinese Medicine Practitioner
252299  Complementary Health Therapists nec
253314  Medical Oncologist
253315  Endocrinologist
253324  Thoracic medicine specialist
254211 Nurse Educator
254311  Nurse Manager
261212  Web Developer
271111  Barrister
312112  Building Associate
312114 Construction Estimator
312911 Maintenance Planner
342411 Cabler (Data and Telecommunications)
411411 Enrolled Nurse


Skills Select Results so Far, and Buying Your Way Into Australia

Posted by Kane on Nov. 28, 2012, 4:49 p.m. in Immigration

Skills Select Statistics

We are now five months into DIAC’s new policy and we have seen some interesting results. As many of you will now be aware, on 1 July this year DIAC introduced Skills Select whereby applicants need to submit an expression of interest and wait for an invitation from DIAC before applying for a visa. 

One of the advantages of this new policy is that the pass mark was lowered from 65 to 60, with those who are nominated by a State Government automatically getting an invitation to apply.

I thought now would be a good time to get a snapshot as to the progress and trends of those who are being invited to apply for a visa to Australia under the skills select program. 

The first selection round took place in August where 100 applicants were selected. The lowest pass mark was 75 and the highest was 85 points. This confirmed my prediction that 75 points would be an ideal score to get if you are to be selected under the independent or family stream skilled migrant category. My initial feelings were that anyone who had a score of 70 or lower would have a better chance of applying through a state government to guarantee an invitation to apply.

The next two selection rounds on 1 September and 15 September saw those who scored 65 points and above given an invitation to apply. Not everybody who scored 65 points obtained an invitation as DIAC will only select a specific number of people in each round. If two applicants both scoring 65 points submit their expressions of interest the one submitting the expression of interest at an earlier point in time will be selected first.  

Already these results have blown my theory out of the water and it appears that 65 points will be a very good score.

Moving on to the October results, namely 1 October and 15 October, we have seen applicants who have scored 60 points being invited to apply. This means that everyone who had 65, 70, 75 and above were given invitations to apply during this month.  So my original theory has now been ripped up and thrown in the bin, and a better ability to forecast trends has been added to my Christmas wish list. 

Whilst we have not yet had the results from November published, results from our clients have been positive where a number have been selected at 60 points and will continue to do so as the program begins to gather momentum.

In August only 100 applicants were selected however in November 3000 applicants were given an invitation to apply. 

There have also been some interesting results through the state sponsorship program. Each state will have their own economic requirements and process applications for state sponsorship nomination through their own processes.  State-sponsored applicants only need to score 60 points to get an invitation. Once your are state sponsored, you are given an invitation to apply for a visa, regardless of how many applicants score more than you. 

In looking at the results of the States who are sponsoring skilled migrants, in the month of September:

  • 503 skilled migrants were sponsored for permanent state sponsorship
  • 73 were sponsored for provisional state sponsorship
  • Western Australia was the state that sponsored the most with 388 nominations approved
  • Victoria was second with 64 nominations approved 
  • Tasmania and Queensland were the least involved states with only 6 and 8 nominations approved respectively.
  • Other states were ACT (46), Northern Territory (13), South Australia (22) and New South Wales (31). 
  • Victoria was the most active state in issuing business skills nominations with 50 approved, followed by Western Australia who issued 6 nomination approvals.

Does a difference in numbers mean that Western Australia wants more migrants than Tasmania? Or are more people applying to go to Western Australia than any other state? 

If only it was so simple. State governments have their own specific requirements simply to ensure that they are attracting the type of skilled worker who will meet the needs of businesses within the state, and they also want to select those who are genuinely interested in remaining in the sponsoring state. Traditionally New South Wales and Victoria have been more popular because the two largest cities in Australia are located within these territories.

DIAC has issued 114,000 places for the skilled migrant programme. These places will include employer nomination, business skills and general skilled migrants. As you can see from the above figures, only 635 invitations were issued by state governments for sponsorship of any of the visas in the skilled category for the month of September. Under independent and family sponsored general skilled migration, 6100 invitations have been issued up to the end of November. 

Each state is given a specific amount of nominations each year. This year, 27,000 places are available through state sponsorship. Given the above results, there are still plenty of places that need to be filled. We will expect the quotas to begin to fill up in the coming months. Also with only less than 7000 invitations issued so far for skilled and business migration, it seems that there are plenty and more invitations that are available for skilled migrants.

Given the fact that the number of occupational places available for state sponsored and independent migration  is limited, one has to say that for different reasons, it makes more sense to be starting the process sooner rather than later.

I know I have mentioned this before but going on the above figures, there has never been a better time to migrate.

 

Significant Investor Category

On 24 November 2012, a new visa category has been implemented by DIAC. This is the significant investor category and is part of the business skills pathway for migration to Australia.

Certainly this visa is targeting those who have significant funds and are interested in investing in managed funds and businesses in Australia. For those of you who can spare $5 million, for a period of four years, and are willing to invest in Australia, then this visa is for you.

Like the other business skill categories, you will be given a provisional Visa in the first instance. Once you have proven that you have invested $5 million in complying investments in Australia over a four-year period, you can then apply for the permanent residency visa.

Unlike the investor visa category that requires you to invest large sum in a state treasury bond, you are able to take advantage of other investment opportunities where the return is much higher. There is also no age limit, meaning that you can migrate to Australia even if you are a centurion (100 years old). 

There are also no language requirements. So if you are having trouble reading this article, your interpreter will be able to tell you that this is not going to be an issue.

One of the other advantages is that the investor only has to spend 40 days per year in Australia over the provisional four year period in order to meet the residency requirements. 

It is fair to say that very few of us would fall into that category, but certainly this is an opportunity for those who have always been interested in moving to Australia but had not met any of the previous requirements such as Language ability, age, business history, etc. to take advantage of becoming a resident.

If your are interested to know more about the new policies and migration trends, please register for one of our free seminars here

 

Forthcoming trips to Singapore, Malaysia and South Africa 

Singapore

Seminar: Saturday 1 December at 11am at the Concorde Hotel

Consultations: 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 December

 

Kuala Lumpur

Seminar: Saturday 8 December at 11am at the Le Meridian Hotel

Consultations: 9, 10 and 11 December

 

Johannesburg

Seminar: Thursday 7 February 2013 at 7pm at the Michelangelo Hotel 

Consultations: 8, 9, 10, 18, 19, 20 February

 

Durban

Seminar: Monday 11 February 2013 at 7pm at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel

Consultations: 12 and 13 February

 

Cape Town

Seminar: Thursday 14 February 2013 at 7pm at the Commodore Hotel

Consultations: 15 and 16 February

 

To book please go to www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars/.

 

The seminars are free to attend however, there is a charge for consultations (if required). 

 

From 

 

The IMMagine Team

www.immagine-immigration.com


Australian Immigration Policy Update

Posted by Myer on Nov. 23, 2012, 2:11 p.m. in Immigration

 

This update covers recent policy changes including; 

1. More occupations sponsored for Victoria and New South Wales and 

2. Proposed changes to post study work visa arrangements for students and longer-term tourist visas for parents of Australian citizens.

 

New South Wales State Sponsorship List

More occupations added (total of 122) and some of the requirements for existing occupations have been lowered.

You can view a copy off the full list here

 

Victorian State Sponsorship List

Occupations added

o        Carpenter and Joiner (331211) 

o        ICT Project Manager (135112)

You can view a complete list of occupations available for sponsorship in Victoria – here 

 

Post study work visas

New post-study work visa arrangements are proposed for introduction in early 2013.  

Graduates of an Australian Bachelor degree, Masters by coursework degree, Masters by 

research degree or Doctoral degree will have access to the post-study work visa

 

Applicants do not need to nominate an occupation on the skilled occupations list  to be eligible to apply for this visa ( this is a big change from current criteria)

Graduates who have completed a Bachelor degree or Masters by coursework degree in 

Australia will be eligible to apply for a two year post-study work visa.  

Graduates who have completed a Masters by research degree or a Doctoral degree in Australia will be eligible to apply for a post-study work visa for three or four years respectively.

 

Students not studying a degree level qualification in Australia will be subject to the status quo, in other words need to  nominate an occupation on the skilled occupations list  and obtain a positive skills assessment and then apply for the subclass 485 visa is a temporary visa that allows an 18 month stay to work iin Australia.

 

Longer Tourist visas for parents of Australians

Under current policy parents can visit Australia for only three months at the time.  Many elderly parents  would therefore  have had  to visit Australia for a period of three months, exit and then re-enter  if they want to spend more time in Australia.

Towards the end of 2012, parents of Australian citizens and permanent residents will be able to apply for Tourist visas to visit Australia for longer periods.

 

 The Department will be considering issuing, on a case-by-case basis:

Tourist visas of up to five years' validity which provide a stay of up to 12 months on each entry to those parents who are outside Australia and are in the Parent (subclass 103) visa queue

Tourist visas of up to three years' validity with 12 months' stay on each entry will be considered for parents who are outside Australia and are not in the Parent visa queue.

Parents will be expected to hold health insurance to cover any healthcare costs during their stay and will have a visa condition limiting applications for further visas while they are in Australia. They will also be expected to leave Australia for extended periods of time – details as to the amount of time that they would be expected to be out of Australia before reientering haven’t yet been released.

 

Forthcoming trips to Singapore, Malaysia and South Africa 

Singapore

Seminar: Saturday 1 December at 11am at the Concorde Hotel

Consultations: 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 December

 

Kuala Lumpur

Seminar: Saturday 8 December at 11am at the Le Meridian Hotel

Consultations: 9, 10 and 11 December

 

Johannesburg

Seminar: Thursday 7 February 2013 at 7pm at the Michelangelo Hotel 

Consultations: 8, 9, 10, 18, 19, 20 February

 

Durban

Seminar: Monday 11 February 2013 at 7pm at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel

Consultations: 12 and 13 February

 

Cape Town

Seminar: Thursday 14 February 2013 at 7pm at the Commodore Hotel

Consultations: 15 and 16 February

 

To book please go to www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars/.

 

The seminars are free to attend however, there is a charge for consultations (if required). 

 

From 

 

The IMMagine Team

www.immagine-immigration.com


Australia looks to Asia

Posted by Myer on Nov. 14, 2012, 3:10 p.m. in Immigration

 

 Australia has recently announced a plan to further its trade and investment ties within the Asian region namely the white paper entitled Australia in the Asian Century which the Prime Minister, Julia Gillard recently unveiled.  In this blog we examine the increased emphasis on ties and trade with Asia in terms of recent statistics relating to migration to Australia by certain Asian (and other) countries.

 Australia’s economic performance has been admirable of late.   It has remained recession free for 21 consecutive years, has an unemployment rate of 5.4% and has a forecast GDP growth of 3.5% for next year.   However there are some storm clouds on the horizon.  China’s slowing growth rate has accounted for lower mineral prices.  That and the high Australian dollar are having a negative impact upon our mining / manufacturing sector. The white paper is a response to ensure Australia remains globally competitive.

 The white paper covers topics from trade and investment, education, immigration, defence and corporate management.

 It seeks to increase Australia’s trade with Asia from 25% to 33% by 2025 and talks about:

1. Offering 12,000 scholarships to allow Asian students, researchers and professionals to study in Australia

2. Ensuring every student in Australia who graduates from high school will have a  knowledge of Mandarin, Bahasa Indonesian and or Japanese.

3. Longer stays for visitors from Asia.

4. The paper also encourages companies to have an increased appreciation of Asia.

 It has been described as a roadmap but also sending a political message to the Asian region that Australia is open for business and ready to meet the region’s growing needs for food, energy, minerals, education and tourism. It is a signal of intent, shifting the focus to Asia  and ensuring that  Australian business and our educational system  make changes to allow for that  shifting focus to  occur.

Because immigration figures will inevitably lag behind political rhetoric, the effects of this change in focus will only likely be felt in years to come. Whilst Asia is increasingly becoming the focus of the Australian government, Australia has long since been an attractive immigration destination for Asian countries, however,  the figures below evidence some interesting anomalies.

Skilled migration [consisting of general skilled migration visas, employer nomination scheme, regionally sponsored migration scheme and business visas] accounted for:

Migration year              Total Skilled Migration

 2010 – 2011                    113,725

2009 – 2010                     107,868

2008 – 2009                     114,777

Given that skilled migration  numbers  appear  to be fairly stable  over the last three years  it’s interesting to see the variations amongst a few  of the  source countries particularly as some of these are IMMagine Australia's markets.

Migration year          Singapore 

2010 – 2011                   1172

2009 – 2010                   1369

2008 – 2009                   1635

Interesting to note that Singapore has experienced a decrease in annual migration over the past three years of approximately 16% however seminar attendance at IMMagine Australia's seminars in Singapore has never been higher. It could be that the increase in seminar attendance we have found during the 2012 year will only be evidenced in the migration figures for the year 2013 – 2012. It might also be that a greater percentage of migrant workers in Singapore are considering migration to Australia than  Singaporean nationals however our experience indicates that there is an even spread.  A tightening of Singapore immigration rules of late would be expected to increase migrant  outflows  from Singapore.

 That is why the next country we have looked at is Philippines as the majority of the migrant labour force in Singapore is comprised of Philippine nationals.

Migration year          Philippines 

2010 – 2011                   7849

2009 – 2010                    6832

2008 – 2009                    5789

Consistent with my comments above we  can see that Philippines has been experiencing average annual migration increases of 16% over the past three years. This is consistent with our experience in the Singapore market. Although we don’t present seminars directly in the Philippines we do have increased exposure to Philippine nationals who are working in Singapore.

Migration year                Malaysia 

2010 – 2011                   4192

2009 – 2010                    4277

2008 – 2009                    4089

Malaysian statistics indicate a consistent demand over the past three years with not much deviation in numbers.   

Migration year                 South Africa 

2010 – 2011                   7595

2009 – 2010                   9885

2008 – 2009                   10,485

There was a relatively large fall in the number of people applying for permanent residence under skilled migration categories between the years 2010 and 2011.  A drop in the order of 2290 people is significant in the context of total migration from South Africa to Australia. Things certainly haven’t improved in South Africa of late and my take on the drop in figures (given the fact that our audience size has been relatively stable over the past few years) is that South Africans are increasingly becoming economic prisoners of South Africa.  

The falling exchange rate and an inability to realize assets such as the family home have meant that significant numbers have been shelving their migration decisions in the hope of an improved exchange rate and more buoyant property market.  As evidenced by our healthy audience sizes in South Africa the perceived need for migration hasn’t lessened. The crippling exchange rate isn’t going to improve so why wait until the Rand reaches 15 Rand to the AU Dollar?

Migration year       China 

2010 – 2011                   20,441

2009 – 2010                    14,505

2008 – 2009                    13,927

A staggering almost 6000 people increase in China over the last migration year tends to support the increased emphasis on China. If one keeps in mind that English language criteria also increased during this period the increase in migration is even more remarkable. In terms of the White papers influence it’s a case of watch this space.

Migration year       United Kingdom 

2010 – 2011                   18,091

2009 – 2010                    18,487

2008 – 2009                    23,177

United Kingdom has long since been regarded as Australia’s traditional source country. Migration figures after the global financial crisis were understandably higher than present but for the last two years migration has been steady with no appreciable rise or decline. This is probably attributable to a more stable economy in the United Kingdom. 

Conclusion

 All countries (like businesses) would like a wealthy trading partner to buy their goods and services however creating a meaningful relationship with a trading partner whether it be a  country or  market for a businesses goods and services requires significant investment  in time, money and  effort.  It requires an understanding as to the needs of the region and to make sure that the prospect of deeper relations with Australia has a distinct benefit  for that particular country. 

We (IMMagine Australia) have learnt that it has taken a significant amount of time and effort to reap the benefits of our investment in our Asian markets namely Singapore and Malaysia. We have been visiting these countries for at least 10 years every two months to present seminars and meet prospective  clients  thereby developing an understanding as to what life is like for our clients and what they are seeking to achieve in Australia.

The Australian government is going to have to invest time and effort not only in quantifying what Australia wants from the deal but what our Asian neighbours would like as well. Developing a relationship such as envisaged in the white paper is a two-way street and there has to be palpable benefits for our Asian neighbours as well.

 

Forthcoming Seminars in Singapore, Malaysia and South Africa 

Singapore

Seminar: Saturday 1 December at 11am at the Concorde Hotel

Consultations: 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 December

 

Kuala Lumpur

Seminar: Saturday 8 December at 11am at the Le Meridian Hotel

Consultations: 9, 10 and 11 December

 

Johannesburg

Seminar: Thursday 7 February 2013 at 7pm at the Michelangelo Hotel 

Consultations: 8, 9, 10, 18, 19, 20 February

 

Durban

Seminar: Monday 11 February 2013 at 7pm at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel

Consultations: 12 and 13 February

 

Cape Town

Seminar: Thursday 14 February 2013 at 7pm at the Commodore Hotel

Consultations: 15 and 16 February

 

To book please go to www.immagine-immigration.com/seminars/

 

The seminars are free to attend, however, there is a charge for consultations (if required). 

 

From 

 

The IMMagine Team

www.immagine-immigration.com


Mirror Mirror on the Wall, Who's the Rudest of Us All?

Posted by Myer on Oct. 10, 2012, 9:17 a.m. in Lifestyle

Mirror mirror on the wall, who's the rudest of us all?

‘How rude’ I thought to myself after my recent seminar in Kuala Lumpur (KL), Malaysia.

I'm not talking about the 45 or so people that attended the seminar but rather the 131 other registrants who didn't turn up. I'm also not referring to the handful of people who advised us that they wouldn't be able to attend the seminar but the 131 registrants that booked for the seminar, received our reminder notices and simply didn't turn up.

This is in marked contrast to the Singapore leg of my journey where of the 400 that registered approximately 200 attended the seminar. Like in KL a few had contacted us to let us know they could not make it and to them we remain grateful.

Does this make Singaporeans more polite than residents of KL ?

What probably prompted this line of thought was a series of introspective newspaper articles that appeared in the Star newspaper whilst I was in KL as to the level of courtesy in Malaysian society. See the edition of 24 July and the article ‘Rude awakening on courtesy’

Good on the Star newspaper for asking the hard questions.

They cited as the top 10 rude Malaysian habits:

• Unsafe driving

• Not obeying signboards

• Snatching parking spaces

• Not giving a seat on public transport for the pregnant or elderly

• Not giving way to exiting passengers on public transport

• Talking loudly on cell phones in public places

• Not holding open elevator doors

• Not saying thank you when someone does something nice for you

• Inconsiderate practices such as leaving shopping trolleys in parking lots

• Being late.

 

To the last item I would add, not arriving at all.

The newspaper article referred to a Reader's Digest poll which placed KL’s rudeness level at 34 of the 36 major cities in the world. The magazine said it was not a scientific survey. Researchers were sent to the cities where they tested people on 3 things:

•  Whether people in front of them would hold the door open for them as they walked into public buildings 20 times.

•  Whether sales assistants said thank you after they'd bought small items from 20 stores.

•   Whether anyone would help pick up papers they'd dropped from a folder in 20 busy locations.

What they found was that KL is lacking in courtesy but it has to be said Singapore didn’t quite cover itself in glory either.

My colleagues at Immagine New Zealand have been quick to point out that Aucklanders are the 7th most polite. Somewhat surprisingly New Yorkers came out on top. Which proves that you can live, work and play in a thoroughly congested megacity but still exercise common courtesies toward your fellow man.

So what is your excuse Kuala Lumpur?

THE MOST COURTEOUS!
 
 CITY     SCORE
1  New York   80%
2 Zurich, Switzerland  77
3 Toronto, Canada  70
4 Berlin, Germany  68
 Sao Paulo, Brazil  68
 Zagreb, Croatia  68
7 Auckland, New Zealand 67
 Warsaw, Poland  67
9 Mexico City, Mexico  65
10 Stockholm, Sweden  63
11 Budapest, Hungary  60
 Madrid, Spain   60
 Prague, Czech Republic 60
 Vienna, Austria  60
15 Buenos Aires, Argentina 57
 Johannesburg, SA  57
 Lisbon, Portugal  57
 London, UK   57
 Paris, France   57

 

THE LEAST COURTEOUS!

 CITY    SCORE
20 Amsterdam, Netherlands 52%
21 Montreal, Canada  50
22 Helsinki, Finland  48
 Manila, Philippines  48
24 Milan, Italy   47
 Sydney, Australia  47
26 Bangkok, Thailand  45
 Hong Kong   45
 Ljubljana, Slovenia  45
29 Jakarta, Indonesia  43
 Taipei, Taiwan  43
31 Moscow, Russia  42
 Singapore   42
33 Seoul, South Korea  40
34 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia 37
35 Bucharest, Romania  35
36 Mumbai, India   32


Does the higher seminar attendance make Singaporeans more polite than Malaysians?

Or perhaps the push factors driving migration from Singapore at this point in time are stronger than those in KL.  Perhaps there is a “feel-good factor” in KL  at present that I am unaware of.  I personally believe that seminar attendance  is influenced  more by the “push” factors operating in a  country at a particular  point in time than the  inherent politeness of a  society.

As most of you are aware we present seminars regularly in South Africa, Singapore and Malaysia and we generally rely upon a significant no-show rate. If this seems incredibly high to you it's probably because you fall within the 33% who wouldn't dream of registering for a seminar and simply not turn up or notify the organizers. If you're thinking “so what” you probably fall in the majority who don’t turn up.

So how polite are Australians?

I've never presented a seminar in Australia so I cannot use my own yardstick in order to determine the politeness/rudeness of society in Australia but the Reader's Digest poll clearly didn't think very much of Sydney ranking this city in 24th place. I like to think that Melbourne would fare better being a more refined lot. Unfortunately [or fortunately] Melbourne was not included in the survey.

 As you read this  I am flying to South Africa for the next round of seminars. Johannesburg (my first stop) ranks a  respectable 15th on the Readers Digest list  so I look forward to seeing all of the 400 registrants at the seminar :).


Seminar schedule for South Africa, Singapore and Malaysia:

South African Seminars – October 2012

Johannesburg:
Seminar being held on Thursday 11 October at 7pm at the Michelangelo Hotel in Sandton.
Consultations will be held on 12, 13, 14, 22, 23 and 24 October in Auckland Park.

Durban:
Seminar being held on Monday 15 October at the Endless Horizons Boutique Hotel in Umhlanga at 7pm.
Consultations being held on 16 and 17 October.

Cape Town:
Seminar being held on Thursday 18 October at the Newland Southern Sun Hotel at 7pm.
Consultations being held on 19 and 20 October at the Commodore Hotel.

Singapore seminar – December 2012

Singapore:
Seminar being held on Saturday 1 December at the Concorde Hotel at 11am.
Consultations will be held on the afternoon of 1 December, and the whole day 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 December.

Malaysia seminar – December 2012

Kuala Lumpur:
Seminar being held on Saturday 8 December at the Le Meridien Hotel at 11am.
Consultations will be held on the afternoon of 8 December, and the whole day 9, 10, 11 and 12 December.