How Do We Prove Our Relationship is Genuine?
Posted by Iain on Oct. 6, 2017, 6 p.m. in Immigration
No matter which resident visa category you apply under – Parent, Skilled, Investor or Partnership, if you have a partner/spouse you need to demonstrate that you are currently (and have been) living together for a minimum of 12 months in a ‘genuine and stable relationship akin to a marriage which is likely to endure’.
There is no requirement that you be married – in fact this makes no difference to the assessment carried out by immigration officers. Living together means simply that – in an exclusive relationship – gay or straight, married or not, young or old - and under the same roof (and presumably in the same bed).
Breaking down the criteria all applicants need to demonstrate that:
- The relationship is genuine – not entered into for any reason other than love (and where the relationship is ‘culturally arranged’, for the ‘right’ reasons even if love doesn’t yet feature)
- It is stable – it is a relationship that is likely to continue into the future
- You are ‘living together’ (note the present tense) –under the same roof (not the same as sharing a PO Box South African readers….)
- There is a degree of financial interdependence
So how do you prove with pieces of paper that you share a common address, a bed, that there is love and that you don’t throw pots and pans at one another every night after work?
The truth is, it is extremely difficult. I don’t know how wedding photos and bank statements prove anything at all.
We base our advice to clients on how a Judge in a family court might assess whether a couple are indeed, for the purposes of divvying up assets in the event of a relationship split, a ‘couple’.
The immigration rule book does not specify what evidence to present, only that whatever is presented must ‘satisfy an immigration officer’. The risk is no two officers will necessarily look at the same evidence and conclude the evidence of the relationship demonstrates it is genuine, stable and so on.
We tend to present two types of evidence – what I call ‘circumstantial’ (but which to me carries the most weight). This might include letters from friends and family, colleagues and associates who are part of your circle of family, friends and social network. Photos of the two of you together through time. Facebook screenshots. Skype logs.
The other is what I call ‘technical’ – evidence of joint ownership of or sharing property (rental agreements for example), insurance policies where your partner (and children) might be beneficiaries of a medical aid programme, invoices, utility bills, tax returns – essentially anything that shows a common address.
No two cases are ever going to be exactly the same and therefore the evidence is always subjective.
The biggest mistake we find, even with our own clients who get highly detailed and personalised instructions on what we want from them based on their personal circumstances, is they provide us their marriage certificate and their childrens' birth certificates. And that’s it.
What they fail to appreciate is that having a marriage certificate does not make a relationship genuine. Anecdotally there’s lots of activity around Auckland right now where former international students, having seen their pathway to residence being blocked by the Government are marrying locals, right, left and centre.
A marriage certificate doesn’t demonstrate ‘stability’ of the relationship either. This is why officers want to see credible evidence going back over at least 12 months of cohabitation – it isn’t watertight evidence but it is indicative.
A rental agreement or title deed to a property doesn’t prove you love each other and share a bed either. Nor I would suggest do joint (or multiple, single name) bank statements. Nor does showing birth certificates of children.
However, this ‘technical’ evidence is what INZ wants to see.
They can insist on interviews between couples or make ‘site visits’ (a euphemism for knocking on your front door without warning to see what the living arrangements are).
I do wish they would make greater use of the interview options because many couples, in very long relationships, organise their affairs separately. It does not diminish their love nor commitment to one another or in any way disprove their claim to a genuine and stable relationship. Too often immigration officers ask for ‘joint’ bank statements – easy to set up but what exactly does it prove?
It is not always easy for immigration officers but it has to be said they very often do not make it easy for themselves. As I was discussing with two senior INZ Managers only yesterday there remains a culture of paranoia and distrust inside INZ and many officers have a hard time appreciating that 90% of applicants are quite genuine and make no attempt to defraud the visa system. These are two managers I have the utmost respect for but even they, if you raise the ‘culture of paranoia and distrust’ observation with them, will immediately trot out an extreme example to demonstrate their distrust is justified. They all tend to focus on the 10% than accept the 90% that are genuine. In the end the risk is all applicants are tarred with the same brush.
It’s a cultural ‘disease’ so common to all Immigration Departments everywhere – it isn’t limited to New Zealand.
The result unfortunately is that applicants are generally treated as guilty and need to prove they are innocent.
This is why we provide our clients with a page of examples of the sort of evidence we need to ‘prove’ they live together once we understand their relationship. We even warn clients that for almost everyone we look after applying for a resident visa under any category, we will present as much evidence that they ‘live together’ as all the other evidence put together!
And I tend to remind people of my golden rules including most importantly ‘assume nothing and suspend logic’.
Until next week...
Iain MacLeod - Southern Man
Share this post
I just sat and read your weekly blog and memories came flooding back of 13 years ago almost to the day that we arrived in NZ!
I remember so clearly you giving us this exact advise about preparing our 'evidence of partnership'. We faithfully followed Myer's suggestions and got our friends to write letters to state how long they'd known us and what they knew of our relationship. We collected photos of us both at each other's family occasions etc. We had such fun collecting the evidence and it was all so worth while.
Thanks Iain......we really wouldn't be still in NZ without you:-)
Replies to this comment